Eidriel wrote:This was an intraday trade I took on GBPJPY just yesterday, I got stopped out of it.
But I would like to ask you all for your opinion on how you all would have done it differently, in terms of analysis, entry, stop loss, and everything.
Technically & structurally there doesn't appear to be anything wrong with it.
All that happened was your stop got hit before the bet managed to return any profit & you should be congratulated for actually having a stop in place at outset.
I've yet to come across a trade that can't be nit-picked in hindsight, but we don't bet on hindsight do we.
To be honest Eidriel I doubt anyone else would have played it differently.
But I would pay very close attention to the comments spotfx posted yesterday.
Q4 is the time when Central Banks are very active in the market distributing & accumulating currency baskets in line with their buy & sell programs & the big firms & funds are aggressively squaring off, trimming out dead wood & re-adjusting their % holdings into years end.
Intraday risk exposure will increase noticeably & you're going to have to be very alert out there as we wind down.
It's not for me or any of the other guys to dictate what you do or how you wish to run your trade books, but just be aware there's a lot of big fish flapping around out there into years end & some of those waves can cause havoc.
jcpfx wrote:the trade went well, and as always i would appreciate thoughts on the initial entry especially
Again, you play it as you see it & technically if that type of set up usually pays you dividends, then you're good to go.
It's the same old risk-opportunity cost/value ratio....& only you know how consistently successful it is.
jcpfx wrote:was it really too risky given that the trade originated 15 mins before UK data and at lows that had been well bid before?
And here's the flip side of that risk-opportunity ratio.
Obviously today it went your way….another day you could not only get trampled in the rush, but experience horrendous slippage (through a stop) if an item of data really catches the market offside.
8 times out of 10 even if it reverses on you & sprints off in the oppositie direction no real harm gets done.....................but it's the other 2 occasions that cause the psychological & financial harm.
As with anything to do with this business - you pays your money & you takes your choice.