jcpfx wrote:Any help to exorcize these demons inside me would help...i see intraday moves like this a lot and there's a big conflict going on inside me because more often then not price does "bounce" enough to give a handsome payday...
They're not demons if you're benefiting consistently from that type of strategy & it's putting money in your account.
The only time you need to start taking stock & considering an alternative is when you experience more debits in the account than credits.
Just because you see folks adopting a slightly different style & outlook to yours doesn't mean you're looking at it from the wrong angle.
I would seriously question abandoning something that feels right & trying to force-fit someone else's model just because it appears simple to them.
We're all wired very differently & what suits one (or more) won't necessarily suit you.
The object of the exercise is to use some or all of this approach to improve what you're already doing.
If you enjoy trading a very specific style such as the one you've mentioned & presented on here, then take your time to experiment with elements of this concept to see if it/they can help with your own model.
It might just be something as simple as scaling back on the quantity of entries & aiming for better quality background set ups.
Only consider changing something if it's showing clear evidence of not working.
If it aint broke it don't need fixing.....maybe just tweaking!
jcpfx wrote:Would love to hear your thoughts on this since we had some sort of common way of thinking!
What I meant by that comment was that when I first started I fell into the groove that most forum participants do.
I loaded up my charts with pivots, fibs, all manner of support & resistance lines, had oscillators underneath the charts, volume, studied candle patterns etc etc.
I assumed that the more confluences & confirmations I could refer to, the higher probability of success I'd achieve.
It wasn't as though I didn't understand how they all worked either, I spent a lot of time researching & confirming my understanding by reading, watching & practicing.
My account was oscillating between a small loss & breakeven for approx 6-8 months before stumbling across these guys.
I pm'd a couple of them & between their specific advice & the material & I read here I slowly began unwinding & dumping all the multi-confluence rubbish & began changing my whole understanding of what I was looking to achieve & how best to approach it.
It's still a work in progress & I continue to make silly mistakes, but at least now I have a solid base & foundation.
I've finally kicked the overtrading drug & have reduced my intraday exposure to a level that I'm satisfied with.
But it didn't happen overnight & it does take some very disciplined application.