Can we trust this man?

[spotfx]

(sum loss pips is missing so that number is estimated)
Can we trust this man?

Phil Newton (aka: Newtron Bomb on the Trade2Win forum) has been around this industry for well over 12 years.
He's been calling live trades in interactive trading rooms (back as far as 2003) for years, while you were no doubt still sucking on your momma's titties.

You stick up a pile of data, part of which you've guessed at, & you have the audacity to suggest this guy is untrustworthy?

Instead of skipping around the trading forums like some clueless fucking jackass, worrying about what other folks are up to, why don't you focus your attentions on this site & maybe think about contributing something considered even remotely worthwhile.

[spotfx]

who gives a fuck what someone else is doing ???
if folks are stupid enough to part with their hard earned before investigating & doing due diligence, then they deserve everything that's coming to them.

If you ( & other grail chasers) spent half as much time attempting to put together a successful model of your own instead of wasting it trying to undermine others, you might begin to earn yourself a tiny modicum of credibility on here.

[jack mason]

A moderate estimate of performance (sum loss pips is missing so that number is estimated)

By your own admission, you have estimated a part of the performance input.

If you're going to attempt to expose or highlight someone as untrustworthy by posting their data on a public forum, then the very least you can do is present factual & accurate information.

Instead of inventing numbers to fill your columns why don't you contact Phil direct & ask him to fill in the blanks?
You might also check with him that the information you're presenting here is an accurate interpretation of the facts.

It's very easy to cast doubts on someone's integrity when they don't have the opportunity to answer.
That type of behavior & activity is both cowardly & repugnant & makes you appear rather stupid & naïve.

[spotfx]

Of course we need excellent non-discretionary trading rules.
If Phil Newtons results stand he is our first choice.

If you're looking for excellent non-discretionary trading rules, then you're chasing shadows sniffing around Phil Newtons info.

He's a discretionary price action trader.

He's one of those rare commodities that actually uses his brain, experience & technical skills to successfully navigate the current rhythm & bias of the market, which of course is constantly changing & evolving.

Unlike a program or robot, he knows when to fully engage & he knows when to back off, step aside or tweak his (strategy) structure to match the price & volatility conditions.

That's why there are so few individuals who can actually do this job successfully & why most of the knuckle heads out there waste their lives chasing scalping profits via the elusive "robot profit machine"